In a message dated 14/01/2013 23:39:15
GMT Standard Time, skylark1970@MAIL.RU
writes: Since human brain resembles a walnut, this quote seems
relevant: the human brain can become the best
torture house of all those it has invented, established and used in millions of
years, in millions of lands, on millions of howling creatures. (Ada, 1.3)
Anthony Stadlen
comments: "Even the clear-thinking
VN could apparently become confused. This is not the only occasion he wrote like
this about "the brain". Did he realise that he was writing metaphorically, and
that no "human brain" has ever invented, established, used or tortured
anything or anybody, just as no pocket calculator has ever calculated, no
typewriter has ever written, and no (non-human) computer has ever computed? Only
people can do those things."
Jansy Mello: After I read A.Sklyarenko's Nabokov quote, I didn't question if
he thought about the walnut resembling "brain" metaphorically or not.
Until the early seventies the confusion between "mind" and "brain" was almost
standard, as if the brain corresponded to the mind, or as if the mind could fit
into the skull, or be situated anywhere in the body.* What it
reminded me, on the contrary, was a famous line that I thought I had read in
Hamlet (therefore, in the context of ADA and "Voltimand"). I tried to locate it
with internet resources and I found out that I must have been mistaken, so I
skipped the quote. It seems that the line was written by John Milton. "The mind
is its own place, and in itself can make a heaven of hell, a hell of
heaven."** (If I was in my twenties, I would have chosen to become a
Milton scholar...He is a genius)
............................................
* - I can date it in the seventies because
British psychoanalyst Wilfred Bion, in his lectures, always stressed this
point, and I suppose he must have had a reason to insist on this
differentiation.
** - **“The
mind is its own place, and in itself can make a heaven of hell, a hell of
heaven..”
― John
Milton, Paradise
Lost