Mike M writes (excerpts): "Does anyone know
who Paul H. Jr might be? Is there any connection between him and Paul Hentzner?
[ ]Although it may be taken to refer to the man (whoever he was) who
occupied this post at the time Hazel Shade was a student, the reader cannot be
blamed for applying it to Paul H., Jr., the fine administrator and inept scholar
who since 1957 headed the English Department of Wordsmith College. We met now
and then (see Foreword and note to line 894) but not often. The Head of the
Department to which I belonged was Prof. Nattochdag - "Netochka" as we called
the dear man. Certainly the migraines that have lately tormented me to such a
degree that I once had to leave in the midst of a concert at which I happened to
be sitting beside Paul H., Jr., should not have been a stranger's
business."[ ] Now to the Foreword, the second alleged reference
to Paul H. Jr. Given that Paul H. Jr is an inept scholar, by a process of
elimination he appears to be the the "Prof. H", whose potential collaboration
with "Prof. C." Charles views with skepticism as co-editors of Shade's
manuscript. I pointed out in an earlier post that these "professors" allude to
Heminges & Condell, the alleged 'editors' of Shakespeare's First Folio, who
as minimally educated actors would have been unqualified for that task.
[ ]What about Paul Hentzner, who knew "the names of things"? There
was a real Paul Hentzner, tutor to a German nobleman, who visited England in
1598, right in the middle of the Shakespeare period [ ] In the long
note to line 894, CK mentions a "visiting German lecturer from Oxford", so that
could relate, tangentially, to Hentzner. Later in the note the German drifts
back in: ""Strange, strange," said the German visitor, who by some quirk of
alderwood ancestry had been alone to catch the eerie note that had throbbed by
and was gone."[ ]. Returning to Paul Hentzner; could Paul H Jr be his son?
Kinbote tells us that Paul (senior?) "pleased John Shade much better than the
suburban refinements of the English Department." -- perhaps the kind of place
where his son worked? The chronology is deficient given that Hentzner's wife
left him in 1950 with his son, presumably a child. 1950 seems to be a
significant date in Pale Fire."
JM: I always thought Paul H. was Prof. Hurley. The
hypothesis about Paul Hentzer rattles my certainties, cultivated at first
through some ancient postings from the Pynchon list, reproduced in the
VN archives.
Carolyn Kunin has recently mentioned Eberthella (Hurley?) and, in this
case, she may have some interesting ideas to add.
There is the connection between Kinbote and one of the Hurley boys, a
party and other items - which I couldn't find using the Archive Google
Search (it's not working as well as it did in the past when I need specific
items from the N-L Archives).
I'm bringing up a selection, although I cannot recollect the gist of the
matters that were being discussed at that time.
[ ] Kinbote
is more taken with the draft version, "the Head of our Department deemed"
because it focuses attention on Paul H., Jr. (Hurley?) who apparently
became "interested" in Kinbote's migraine headaches and later discounted
Kinbote's ability to edit Shade's poem, going so far as to say that Kinbote has
a "deranged mind" and suggest legal action. Also, Hurley was invested in writing
the Shade biography before Kinbote butted in. Line 71 commentary mentions this,
too. Kinbote thinks that his own commentary will change Paul H's mind about
Kinbote's sanity and his ability to edit the work. An enigmatic line ends the
little section, "Southey liked a roasted rat for supper - which is especially
comic in view of the rats that devoured his Bishop." This is apparently a double
slam; he's referring to Paul H. eating crow and that he has been outmatched in
the metaphoric chess game Kinbote thematically conjures up to keep the
poem.Along those lines a question; is this the Bishop that the chess
sophisticate "go(es) on a wild goose chase" to obtain while the na�ve
serendipitously sees and acquires? (I can't find where I found that. Probably
Brian Boyd's "Shade and Shape." ) But instead of eating crow, Kinbote has Paul H. eating a rat. Is
this for "ratting" on him?"
NABOKV-L Archives - LISTSERV Archives at
LISTSERV.UCSB.EDU https://listserv.ucsb.edu/lsv-cgi-bin/wa?A2=nabokv-l;7b0b960e...
"
"I do not know whether the following will stand up under
further scrutiny (exact dates, etc.) but perhaps the most famous "serving" of
rat in the cinema occurs in "Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?", a film released
in 1962, the same year that PF was published. Most will know the plot of
this cult film. It strikes me that the interdependence of the
nostalgically mad Jane (Bette Davis) and her wheelchair-bound (and about to be
"rediscovered") actress sister (Joan Crawford) bears a certain relationship to
the Charles Kinbote-John Shade duet? And in the end there is the question:
Who exactly has driven whom mad. Did VN perhaps see the film and find the
dynamic stimulating? I would like to think that VN saw, and enjoyed, this
bizarre, and comical, b&w classic![ ] (Paul Hurley "chairs"
the English Department...?) Alternatively, is it too simple to think that
Southey's name comes to mind (in the context of a person - Hurley
- behaving like a "rat") because Southey was Laureate (Shade) to
the King (Kinbote), and had written a famous poem about rats pursuing a Bishop
(chesspiece) to a Castle? VN does lead one a merry dance, doesn't he?!"
David Krol text/html - LISTSERV 16.0 - NABOKV-L
Archives https://listserv.ucsb.edu/.../wa?...
" Paul Hurley, Jr., becomes head of the English Department at
Wordsmith (n. 376-377)." (Jerry Friedman) .