There's a book that offers connections between
Nabokov's story "The Assistant Producer" and Erich Rohmer's movie "The Triple
Agent," namely Nabokov's cinematic afterlife, authored by Ewa
Mazierska. Ed. Jefferson, N.C.McFarland, ©2011.
Summary provided by the
publisher:"This work offers critical studies of films that adapted works by
Vladimir Nabokov. One of the most screened twentieth century authors (with over
10 books adapted for cinema), his works are full of quirky and forbidden
romance, and his writing is renowned for its cinematic qualities. A final
chapter compares the similarities between Nabokov and Jean-Luc Godard" and a
list of its chapters:
Humbert
between dignity and romanticism : Lolita by Stanley Kubrick (1962) and Adrian
Lyne (1997) --
Going blind in swinging London : Laughter in the dark (1969)
by Tony Richardson --
Nabokov, or the logic of late capitalism : King, queen,
knave (1972) by Jerzy Skolimowski --
Escape into a different person, escape
into a different reality : Despair (1978) by Rainer Werner Fassbinder
--
Rememberance of things unspoken : Mademoiselle O by Jérôme Foulon
--
Duel in contemporary Estonia : An affair of honor (1999) by Valentin Kuik
--
Nabokov as a gentle feminist : The Luzhin defence (2000) by Marleen Gorris
--
From b-movie script to Greek tragedy : "The assistant producer" by
Vladimir Nabokov, and Triple agent (2004) by Eric Rohmer --Vladimir Nabokov and
Jean-Luc Godard.[Cf. Nabokov's cinematic afterlife ]
Another link found in
the internet relating:Rohmer and Nabokov: "Nabokov knew Nadezhda
Plevitskaya, liked her voice, but hated her taste in songs. He wrote the
story, "The Assistant Producer," about Skoblin and his wife. A famous
Russian popular singer marries a White Russian General, who obsessed with
becoming the head of the remnant of the White Army becomes a triple agent
working for the Whites, the Germans, and Soviets in order to eliminate all
the other Generals who stand in his way: http://moshkow.rsl.ru/koi/NABOKOW/ap.txt (Paul Gallagher on the real-life characters who inspired Rohmer's
Triple Agent) "
Here's a BBC Movies review of "Triple Agent"
(2004) by Jamie Russell that ignores Nabokov's short-story and
its casting "in the form of a film," or his early novel "Laughter
in the Dark" - even after bringing up VN's and Rohmer's shared source
in real events and the latter's plans to "insert his characters into a 1930s
news reel footage much as that earlier film used digital technology to put the
protagonists into 18th century painting."
"True lies are given an historical spin in Eric
Rohmer's invigoratingly ambitious Triple Agent. A period tragedy in the
vein of the octogenarian French New Wave director's The Lady And The
Duke, it's very loosely based on the true story of White Russian Army
general Fyodor (Serge Renko) who played a triply duplicitous role as a spy in
30s France, deceiving not only Marxists, Soviets and Fascists but also his
long-suffering wife Arsinoé (Katerina Didaskalou) until the forces of history
finally caught up with him.The year is 1936 and Europe is in turmoil. Caught in
the middle of the clash between Fascism and Communism are a group of
aristocratic Russian exiles who've fled to France from Stalin's Russia. Among
them is Fyodor, a soldier turned pen pusher who's rumoured to be "very
well-informed". A secretive, duplicitous man he's an enigma even to his Greek
wife Arsinoé who slowly begins to realise that he's actually a spy. Triple
Agent was originally planned as a formal companion to The Lady And The
Duke, with Rohmer planning to insert his characters into 1930s newsreel
footage much as that earlier film used digital technology to put the
protagonists into 18th century paintings. Sadly, the idea proved too expensive
and unwieldy and Triple Agent instead uses the newsreels in a more
conventional form - as a backdrop to Arsinoé's relationship with her
husband.
As with all Rohmer's films, its words not action that count.
Triple Agent delivers a heady thrill as characters pick over the events
of the period, chattering about 30s politics, the joys of Cubist art and the
gathering storm that would tear Europe apart over the course of the next decade.
Focusing in on Fyodor and Arsinoé, Rohmer manoeuvres the espionage theme through
sitting room and bedroom, distilling the tumultuous events of 20th century
history into an intimate drama about the psychology of trust and deceit.
Director and Writer: Eric Rohmer Stars: Katerina Didaskalou, Serge Renko,
Cyrielle Claire, Grigori Manukov, Dimitri RafalskyGenre: Drama, Cinema: 29
October 2004 .":
"It is a notorious,
and notoriously unresolved, tale of espionage: a one-time White Russian general,
in exile in Paris, connives with both the Soviets and the Nazis in the
mid-1930s. Hoping to use a day out with his wife, once a popular singer in her
homeland, as his alibi, he slips away from her for a brief time, during which he
oversees the kidnapping of another general, his superior at the White veteran
association he belongs to. That general is never seen again. The triple agent,
confronted with a note in which his victim confides of misgivings about his
colleague and the meeting he arranged, slips away from his would-be captors. He,
too, is never seen again. Seeking a scapegoat, the authorities pounce on the
agent's wife, who is convicted and dies in prison.
When Vladimir Nabokov
adapted the story of General Miller (the victim), Nicholas Skobline (the agent),
and Nadine Plevitskaia (the wife), for one of his short fictions, he actually
cast it in the form of a film, a melodrama by turns florid and tawdry and
sometimes rife with that quality, poshlust, which Nabokov so beautifully
elaborates on in his study of of Gogol. (If you haven't read that study, by all
means do; in any case, for our purposes here, let's say that poshlust stands for
"aspirational kitsch.") "Tonight we shall go to the movies," its mysterious
narrator of "The Assistant Producer" says at the beginning, before lavishing
some rueful contempt on the singer he refers to as "La Slavska." *
"The
producer is a mere assistant because Russian history has begotten a stream of
B-pictures that are in their way as distorted as the monstrous jokes
perpetrated by Soviet revisionists," the ever-astute Nabokovian Arthur Appel,
Jr., notes in his wonderful book Nabokov's Dark Cinema. Discussing the
story's cinematic antecedents and analogs, he notes that the story's "bit
players are as accomplished as Akim Tamiroff and Mischa Auer." He mentions Lewis
Milestone's The North Star, released in the same year that "The
Assistant Producer" was published, 1943.
For myself, Nabokov's literary
mise-en-scene is rather evocative of von Sternberg:
"And then, in
traditional contrast, pat comes a mighty burst of music and song with a rhythmic
clapping of hands and stamping of booted feet and we seen General Golubkov's
staff in full revelry—a lithe Georgian dancing with a dagger, the self-conscious
samovar reflecting distorted faces, the Slavska throwing her head back with a
throaty laugh, and the fat man of the corps, horribly drunk, braided collar
undone, greasy lips pursed for a bestial kiss, leaning across the table
(close-up of an overturned glass) to hug—nothingness, for wiry and perfectly
sober General Golubkov has deftly removed her and now, as they both stand facing
the gang, says in a cold, clear voice: 'Gentlemen, I want to present you my
bride'—and in the stunned silence that follows, a stray bullet from outside
chances to shatter the dawn-blue windowpane, after which the roar of applause
greets the glamourous couple."**
There are no scenes of such vulgar exuberance in
Triple Agent, the imagining of the Miller/Skobline/Plevitskaia affair
that Eric Rohmer made in 2004. The Skobline figure, here named Fiodor and played
with oft-disturbing intensity by Serge Renko, is never even seen in uniform, let
alone celebrating with his troops. No, the film is set entirely in Paris,
opening with the 1936 election of the Popular Front. It eschews action quite
deliberately; everything you might expect to see in a film with the title Triple
Agent is left off screen. Which is not to say the film is without suspense, or a
form of action. In perhaps the most crucial departure from the known facts of
the case, Rohmer completely changes the wife's identity. Rather than a fellow
Russian, and a popular singer of gypsy songs, Fiodor's wife is a shy, beautiful
painter of Greek origin named Arsinoé (Katerina Didaskalou). Not very much seems
to happen in the film's first quarter. Arsinoé makes the acquaintance of the
couple upstairs, who are Communists; she and Fiodor and the neighbors have some
intriguing conversations about art and politics, and figurative versus abstract
art. These don't move the plot along a bit, but contribute a resonant thematic
element. We are given the impression that Fiodor and Arsinoé have a relatively
quiet life, but are passionately attached to each other. But as political events
ramp up, Fiodor's perversity begins to reveal itself. His allegiances seem to be
all over the place, and when it's pointed out to him, he launches elaborately
improvised self-justifications. And when he's not doing that, he almost waxes
smug about his duplicity. At a lunch with a cousin, a former Russian royal
looking for work with Fiodor's organization, and right in front of his wife, he
taunts the young man: "Sometimes it's wiser to be truthful than to lie, so you
won't be believed. Don't you believe me?" And then fixes on him the gaze that we
see in the screen cap at top.Then follows one of the most extraordinary series
of shots in Rohmer. Not at all known for quick cutting, he almost jumps from the
medium closeup at top to the one below, and then cuts three more times in less
than five seconds, thusly:
"Can't you decide?" he asks his wife,
coldly. The quick cuts work like a glass of cold water thrown in one's face;
it's a turning point in the film, and in the characters' marriage. By the time
the climax is at hand, Fiodor has got Arsinoé so confused that she breaks down
in tears of joy when he emphatically tells her that he's not a Nazi. And he's
not, probably. But what is he, exactly. Against a backdrop of political
intrigue, Rohmer presents a moral tale of how people make themselves unknowable
not only to each other but to themselves. Nabokov, on the other hand, examines
role-playing, and, as always, the gap between reality and perception, and wrings
a peculiar poignancy out of a scenario into which he has injected very little of
what you might call the "human element." "The story brilliantly inverts life and
art," observes Nabokov biographer Brian Boyd, "[E]vents appear to be purloined
from movieland, but in fact come straight from life—which itself seems to have
imitated bad art."..."If 'history' means 'a written account
of events'...then let us inquire who actually—what scribes, what
secretaries—took it down and how qualified they were for the job,"
Nabokov said in an interview with Phillip Oakes in 1969. "The Assistant
Producer" serves up "history" twice removed, not just as a movie, but as a
Hollywood movie (as La Slavska arrives at Golubkov's camp, the audience is shown
"a plain littered with bodies somewhere in Ventura County) out of Nabokov's
imagination. It was the first short story he wrote in English, three years after
coming to America from Paris...where he had been a neighbor of General
Miller.
(Posted at 12:23 PM in Auteurs, Great Art, Literary interludes |
Permalink )
............................................................................................
* - Don B.Johnson works
over Mascodagama's last act and a Crimean dancer - which are perhaps
distantly connected to the "La Slavska" pastiche and
some spying "multiple agents" - in his
article "Ada’s Last Tango” in
Dance, Song and Film
Abstract "Van’s brief stage career as a
maniambulist concludes with a London performance in which he dances a tango with
a female partner from the Crimea. The unnamed song to which they dance, mostly
widely known as “The Last Tango” is one that was very popular in Europe in the
period before and after WWI. The Russian version, “Poslednee Tango,” supplied
the plot for a 1918 Russian film adaptation starring Vera Xolodnaya whose work
was well known to both VN and his “Tamara” from their furtive afternoon trysts
in wintry Saint-Petersburg cinemas. Circumstantial evidence suggests that
Nabokov heard the song in his Crimean stay (if not before), and likely saw the
film. Nor was this VN’s only filmic experience in the Crimea. In Drugie berega,
he describes a bizarre encounter with the leading movie star of the day—Ivan
Mozzhukhin—in what is described as a rehearsal scene for a movie loosely based
on Tolstoy’s Hadji Murad, later released under the title Der Weiss Teufel. The
paper examines the role of these musical and cinematic elements as they are
interwoven into Ada and Speak Memory. The talk is accompanied by a recording of
“The Last Tango” and fragments of the eponymous film, as well as the Mozzhukin
feature." (Ada 's “Last Tango” in Dance, Song and Film -
Cycnos
revel.unice.fr/cycnos/index.html?id=1045 -)
For example, as we read in
"Ada": "Rumors, carefully and cleverly
circulated by Mascodagama’s friends, diverted speculations toward his being a
mysterious visitor from beyond the Golden Curtain, particularly since at least
half-a-dozen members of a large Good-will Circus Company that had come from
Tartary just then (i.e., on the eve of the Crimean War) — three dancing girls, a
sick old clown with his old speaking goat, and one of the dancers’ husbands, a
make-up man (no doubt, a multiple agent) — had already defected between
France and England, somewhere in the newly constructed ‘Chunnel.’ "
Nabokov was not as
impervious to music as he makes one think. In a quote by Andrew Field
from VN's review of Sartre's La Nausée, Nabokov
mentions that he has "taken the trouble to
ascertain that in reality the song is a Sophie Tucker one written by the
Canadian Shelton Brooks" (VN is observing on Sartre's
having attributed a lot of importance "to an
American song on the café phonograph. Roquentin would like to be as crisply
alive in this song, which "saved the Jew [who wrote it] and the Negress [who
sang it]")
** - One item with disguised references to
theatrical distortions, spying and garbled information, from ADA,
related to Nabokov's "The Assistant Producer" now described as
typical of "von Sternberg's style":
"Moreover, the tropical moonlight she had just bathed in.... the
next scene, which started with a longish intermezzo staged by a ballet company
whose services Scotty had engaged, bringing the Russians all the way in two
sleeping cars from Belokonsk, Western Estoty. In a splendid orchard several
merry young gardeners wearing for some reason the garb of Georgian tribesmen
were popping raspberries into their mouths, while several equally implausible
servant girls in sharovars (somebody had goofed — the word ‘samovars’ may have
got garbled in the agent’s aerocable) were busy plucking marshmallows and
peanuts from the branches of fruit trees. At an invisible sign of Dionysian
origin, they all plunged into the violent dance called kurva or ‘ribbon boule’
in the hilarious program whose howlers almost caused Veen (tingling, and
light-loined, and with Prince N.’s rose-red banknote in his pocket) to fall from
his seat."