Steve Norquist ("compare
Farmer's comment with another, from ADA, using Nabokov's words: "the lewd, ludicrous and vulgar mistake of the Signy-Mondieu
analysts consists in their regarding a real object, a pompon, say, or a pumpkin
as a significant abstraction of the real object," but I got
nowhere...
Farmer's comment seems clear enough to me...Nabokov's, on the contrary,
remains puzzling ) I believe your Ada comparison is on the
right track, in that VN's words are further evidence of his rejection, stated
emphatically in
Speak, Memory, of Freud's mundane and vulgar idea that a
madman might reconstruct his personal "reality" by scouring repressed memories
for "kernels of truth" (childhood abuse, pompoms, pumpkins, whatever) to
understand how they define him. VN's take might be that a madman's inner
"kernel of sanity" can only blossom posthumously, in an aesthetic and spiritual
otherworld. A discussion of the VN-"Signy Froit" argument may be seen, i.e., at
http://www.libraries.psu.edu/nabokov/cohen4.htm
and Brian Boyd's annotations at Ada Online might give you some useful ideas as
well:
http://www.ada.auckland.ac.nz/index.htm
JM: Steve, my point was not to
argue for, or against, Freud (fetish, in the modern sense,
derives from the writings of Marx and Freud), but to make sense of
Nabokov's sentence. Now I must also try to
make sense of your answer with its madmen and "kernels of
sanity"!
Let me try to pick the matter up from a
different vertex. Nabokov often stressed his realization that "reality is a
very subjective affair," but here he writes quite naturally about "real
objects" to suggest that not only concrete entities (pompons or
pumpkins) are such "real objects," but that there are other similarly
"real" entities (related to the "significant abstraction of the real object.").
I rather enjoyed your idea that there
is madness and sanity in the spiritual world. Such a
possibility hadn't occurred to me before, even though your suggestion
might be very Nabokovian (should Hazel, for example, be seen as a
collaborative,
sane and generous ghost!).