Subject:
Re: [NABOKV-L] CHW to MR re: American v. European  
  From:
Andrew Brown <as-brown@comcast.net> <mailto:as-brown@comcast.net>   
  Date:
Wed, 10 Jan 2007 13:19:40 -0500    
  To:
Vladimir Nabokov Forum <NABOKV-L@listserv.ucsb.edu> <mailto:NABOKV-L@listserv.ucsb.edu>   

Emily Dickinson was every bit as American as Mencken, whose boisterous rhetoric was suited only to the time in which he had his greatest success, the Twenties.  Note how Mencken is mentioned disparagingly by two characters in Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises.
Even at that early stage, (Sun came out, or was written, in about ‘26, I think) Mencken’s reputation was something on a par with Jimmy Breslin of the ‘60s. Mencken couldn’t have held his own for ten minutes in a mano a mano with William Safire when Safire was in fighting trim.

I don’t think it’s too much of an exaggeration to say that Mencken was really a Rush Limbaugh endowed with brains and literacy.

Sandburg, too, is very much trapped in his time, like a cicada shell stuck to a tree. No one reads him today except scholars who for some reason have been forced to.

Americans who were true Americans and yet able to transcend the time trap include Poe, Sam Clemens (I don’t use that goofy moniker he rigged up for himself); please read Sam’s The Innocents Abroad. It is a timelessly funny, fearfully insulting, recklessly honest look at old Europe and the old (but smoldering) Middle East by a wised-up provincial American.

Ambrose Bierce, clever and concise; Vincent Millay (she chose the masculine version of her name) one of the greatest — maybe the greatest — composer of sonnets in the 20th century; and, of course, F. Scott Fitzgerald.

It’s only my opinion, but I think if one wanted to examine the American voice of the first half of the last century, one might choose the lyrical optimism of early Fitzgerald, balanced with the deflating humor of Ring Lardner, rather than the journalism of Mr. Mencken. As an American reader, and a confessed provincial who has had the luck to do some traveling in other lands, I would nominate the American prose or verse stylists above as examples to compare with VN.  But, as I say, these are just suggestions.


Respectfully,

Andrew Brown



Search the Nabokv-L archive at UCSB

Contact the Editors

All private editorial communications, without exception, are read by both co-editors.

Visit Zembla

View Nabokv-L Policies