----- Original Message -----
Sent: Friday, May 20, 2005 5:26 PM
Subject: Fw: Fw:Pale Fire and Crown Jewels/Disa laughs? J-2May
20
In her message to the list, Carolyn observed that the expression "family
jewels" was not employed by Kinbote.
Mike wrote: The "family jewels" joke, it seems to me,
is more of a verbal gag than a visual one(...) The family jewels are, so to
speak, where the family jewels would be expected to be
According to Kunin, Kinbote speaks often, but
only, of "crown jewels" - and she added " the cold hard fact is
that, even in the novel Pale Fire, there is no actual Zembla, hence no
actual crown jewels. So if the country & its jewels are paste, why
not just let the Russians have them and keep the last laugh for
yourself?
Carolyn indirectly reminded me
of the 1966 interview made by Alfred Appel Jr. ( it can be checked in SO page
92)
A.Appel Jr: As a closing question, sir, may I return to
Pale Fire: where please, are the crown jewels hidden? *
VN: "In the
ruins, sir, of some old barracks near Kobaltana (q.v); but do not tell it to
the Russians"
Following the reference where we
find: *- One hesitates to explain a joke, but readers
unfamiliar with Pale Fire whould be informed that the hiding place of the
Zemblan crown jewles is never revealed in the text, and the Index entry under
"crown jewels", to
which the reader must now refer, is less than
helpful. "Kobaltana" is also in the Index.
When we search the Index, now in PF, we
have:
Index: Kobaltana, a once fashinable mountain resort near the
ruins of some old barracks now a cold and desolate spot of difficult access
and no importance but still remembered in military families and forest
castles, not in the text. (PF page 310)
After
so much searching around imaginary lands after imagined paste
crown jewels that were described in very real written texts, I no
longer wonder why did Disa laugh, but why should we let the Russians keep
the jewels ( to have our last laugh, according to C.Kunin ) or why
not tell them in the first place( as VN jokingly
recommended)?