|
Meanwhile: My uncle finally gets
his Russian passport |
Serge Schmemann IHT
Wednesday, June 09, 2004
|
CAEN,
France
After the grand ceremonies on the Normandy beaches on Sunday for
the anniversary of D-Day, President Vladimir Putin was driven to the
ornate préfecture here for a series of meetings, and to hand my
83-year-old uncle his first passport.
It was a brief and quiet
meeting, but it was well reported in the Russian media. The notion that a
Russian émigré would live his entire life in France without taking any
citizenship because, as Andrei Schmemann explained, "I'm a Russian,"
seemed as striking to the Russian reporters as it had been to Nikita
Mikhalkov, the Russian filmmaker who included my uncle in a recent
documentary about the Russian emigration. His story reached Putin, who
apparently decided that ending Andrei Schmemann's estrangement was a
perfect fit in his efforts to build bridges to the Russian
diaspora.
As he handed Uncle Andrei the passport, Putin said the
tumult of the 20th century had left millions of Russians outside their
homeland. "Many of them, the large majority, and you are one of them,
ardently maintained the traditions of our country," he said.
"I
have awaited this moment my entire conscious life," my uncle replied. "I
was raised in the spirit of Russian traditions, culture and Orthodoxy. I
have always been a Russian in my soul." He spoke clearly and without an
accent, noted the Russian reporters; "he is old," wrote one, "but his
clear voice and straight back reveal a military record."
In fact he
never served in the military. Nor was my uncle ever a die-hard Russian
nationalist. He worked until retirement in a high- end art gallery on the
Left Bank, he still indulges a taste for fine wine and fine food, and in
general he has always lived quite happily in Paris. But throughout his
life, he has also been an example of one of the phenomena of our age - the
lifelong émigré.
Every age has known its exiles and emigrants, of
course, imperial Russia not least among them. But the massive upheavals of
the 20th century found entire peoples - many fleeing Communist
totalitarianism - stranded outside their homelands and struggling to
continue living the life of their lost nation in another land. On a lesser
historical scale than the Jews, the most remarkable of history's scattered
nations, some created entire émigré cultures, with their own history,
literature, politics, religion and promised land. For some, like the
Germans, Koreans and Vietnamese, the dream was reunification; for others,
like the Hungarians, Poles or other East Europeans, it was to eventually
return home.
The Russian experience was extraordinary in that the
Bolshevik revolution killed or drove out almost the entire intellectual,
military, social and commercial elite of a vast empire. Nabokov, Bunin,
Wrangel, Nijinsky, Kandinsky, Koussevitzky, Chaliapin, Balanchine,
Kerensky, Sikorsky, grand dukes, counts, generals, archbishops, professors
- all who were not killed fled to the West, to be joined over the decades
by new waves of exiles.
In effect, an entire culture was abruptly
transferred west, its bearers convinced, especially in the first decade
after the Russian revolution, that their calling was to safeguard
"Russianness" as long as the motherland was captive.
The Russian
émigré culture sank its strongest roots in Paris. These days, sites like
the St. Alexander Nevsky Cathedral on Rue Daru or the cemetery at Sainte
Geneviève des Bois - where the likes of Felix Yusupov, the killer of
Rasputin, and Rudolf Nureyev, the ballet star, are buried - are enjoying a
steady stream of tourists from Russia.
Inevitably, however, the
emigration gave in to assimilation and dispersion, especially in America
and other countries with a tradition of immigration. My father (and
Andrei's twin brother), Alexander Schmemann, a Russian Orthodox priest and
theologian, took our family to the United States in 1951 and found his
Zion there. He died in 1983. In a talk he gave in 1977, he ruminated on
the peculiar world into which he was born: "I, for one, never emigrated
from anywhere: I was already born an 'emigrant,' and although I have never
been in Russia, I have always, since I was conscious, identified myself
unequivocally as a Russian - and this despite my having lived almost 30
years in France and accepted French culture as something very close,
almost my own. In recent years, I can say without exaggeration that I not
only have embraced America, but have dedicated the major part of my life's
work to it."
But my uncle never questioned what world he belongs
in. It wasn't a political act not to take citizenship, he explained.
Accepting a French passport, he believed, was to become French, which he
was not. He traveled on a Nansen passport, a travel document for refugees
first adopted by the League of Nations in 1922, and he enjoyed all French
social benefits (his wife, son and two daughters all have French
citizenship). A tall, athletic man, he had attended a Russian military
school founded by émigrés in Paris (whence the military bearing), and he
became the head of the association of Russian cadets. In recent years, he
helped found several such schools in Russia - including one in Petersburg
of which Putin spoke knowledgeably. Schmemann also directed a Russian
scout organization and its summer camp, and he sat on many an émigré
board.
In short, he remained a Russian. At 83, with an ailing wife,
he may not use that new passport a lot. But he is no longer an émigré.
|