----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, August 07, 2003 4:21 AM
Subject: The Russian Lolita &c.
I would like to contribute to the Lolita thread. In
Julian Barnes's Flaubert's Parrot, chapter 6 "Emma Bovary's Eyes", there is a
short discussion of mistakes in literature, and among his examples the narrator
Geoffrey Braithwaite mentions Nabokov: "Nabokov was wrong - rather surprising,
this - about the phonetics of the name Lolita." I wonder what made him think
so?
Also, while we're on this topic of mistakes. The French monthly
Magazine Litteraire, the July-August, 2003, issue, features an interview with an
Argentinian-born writer, translator, essayist Alberto Manguel who says: "Quand
Nabokov traduit Eugène Onéguine et veut garder les petites faiblesses,
les petites erreurs, il ne fait qu’ajouter ses laideurs à un texte anglais qui
n’en a pas besoin."
And returning to the Lolita question. There are
some differences between the English and the Russian versions. In the Russian
monthly "Innostrannaya Litaratura" there was a short article on the subject,
but, unfortunately, I can't say in what issue it appeared
(in the early 1990s I think). Apart from Aleksandr Svirilin's find (the
missing paragraph in Part 2, Chapter 3), in the English
original (Part 2, Chapter 33) Humbert Humbert says: "I said didn't she
think 'vient de', with the infinitive, expressed recent events so much
more neatly than the English 'just' with the past?" - while
the Russian version goes: "В самом деле, - сказал я (пользуясь дивной
свободою, свойственной сновидениям). - Вот так судьба! Бедный мальчик пробивал
нежнейшие, невосстановимейшие перепоночки, прыскал гадючьим ядом - и ничего, жил
превесело да ещё получил посмертный орденок." What was it that made VN
change the dry piece of comparative grammar in English
to the physiological particularity and ophidian
venom in Russian? In the "Post Script" to the Russian translation of
Lolita he wrote that he had held back with an arm of
iron the daemons which had incited him to changes and omissions. It
doesn't seem, with all the evidence amassed, to be the case after all, does
it?
(Dear Don, I don't know if it will be of any
interest or value to Nabokovians, but in White Teeth, page 362, Zadie Smith
invokes some Cockney housewife with a rather peculiar English name -
Mrs Winterbottom. The author seems to need a funny peculiar name
here. In "Conversation piece, 1945" Nabokov says that Sinepuzov (blue
belly) is a surname "which affects a Russian imagination in much the same
way as Winterbottom does an English one". A bit
of trivia.)
My best regards and please excuse the
long-windedness.
Sergey Karpukhin,